Thank You for the helping
hands!
By:
Rich Woldt CPP, CFE
CEO: The Risk Management Learning Center
Licensed Private Detective
Homeland
Security Instructor - ACFEI – Level III
Instructor: Incident Command System (ICS) & National
Incident Management System (NIMS)
Thank you Emergency Government, Law Enforcement, Fire
Departments and Volunteers, Veterans, our business
community, and all other responding agencies and
residents for the helping hands you continue to offer
the victims of Hurricane Katrina. You’ve all made us
very proud! Katrina was, God willing, a once in a life
time event for our country. She devastated over 90,000
square miles not once but in waves; starting with the
wrath of a class 5 Hurricane, than levee breaks and
“explosive” toxic waste water, than victim on victim
aggression, public ridicule and the most unfortunate
political finger pointing. What next? What went wrong?
It will take years to sort it all out. For now, we must
regroup, focus on rescues and recovery and move forward.
I offer the following Incident Command System (ICS)
update to help us regroup, fine tune our response and
move toward recovery. Throughout the document, I’ve
attempted to introduce procedures and processes
recommended by the National Incident Management System
(NIMS).
Following their emergency operations plans,
government officials surveyed the damage and set
“the tone from the top” declaring the disaster and
authorizing “whatever response assets were needed would
be made available.” Next, response personnel and
resources were made mission ready and positioned in
staging areas within striking distance yet out of harms
way. This is where the
process appears to have broken down. Some staging areas
were not out of harms way and some found themselves
incredibly short of resources, resulting in a breakdown
in ordering and distribution systems.
Not unlike 9-11, Katrina gave us an advance
lesson in ICS Staging Area management. Responding to
9-11 we learned that rushing to respond endangers first
responders and can destroy responder assets. We learned
it again in Kentucky when a bogus anthrax scare
eliminated over 30% of police, fire, and hospital
response assets within 20 minutes because responders
failed to follow what we now consider National Incident
Management System (NIMS) procedures. Staging for a level
5 Hurricane requires greater geographical spacing than
when staging for a localized tornado, flood, or
terrorist attack.
The only villain in the Gulf was
Katrina. She threatened, she pounced and she traumatized
our country. If there is a bright side, she taught us
much. Next time, we’ll be more willing to evacuate. Next
time we’ll have more responders trained in the National
Incident Management System. Before she returns we’ll
invest in environmental changes that might replace
barrier reefs and we’ll adopt construction standards
similar to those upgrading buildings along the Florida
coast and Federal buildings since the bombing in
Oklahoma City. We Americans are a hearty bunch. We’ll
recover and move on. For now, let’s be good to our
neighbor’s, good to ourselves and good to all those
making a good faith effort on our behalf.
Following
with permission to reprint is our Risk Management
Learning Center update on the ICS for Hurricane
Katrina. (This can be downloaded from my RMLC web site)
Rich
Woldt CPP, CFE
CEO: The Risk Management Learning Center
This is a review of
the Incident Command System (ICS) and The National
Incident Management System (NIMS) response issues
relative to Hurricane Katrina –
Issued by the Risk
Management Learning Center
9-11-05
Please use this review of ICS processes when briefing
others and during changes in Unified Commands. Post it
at your Emergency Operation Center (EOC) and reprint it as a training handout. Remember to begin your briefings
and debriefings with a Thank You for a job well done!
(Note: This handout can and should be personalized for
your Community, County, Parish, Region, District,
Municipality, and State recovery personnel.)
Rich Woldt CPP, CFE, –
Instructor: NIMS - Homeland Security – Contingency
Planning, Security & Risk Management
Response to Katrina –
What went wrong?
The
finger pointing is a normal reaction during and after
every traumatic incident. It’s driven by the scope of
the incident, number of victims, and perceived inability
to respond as quickly as might be expected. Hurricane
Katrina, while predicted days in advance, was no more
expected by those choosing to stay in New Orleans than
an earthquake is expected by those living in San
Francisco. Those who think they could have done a better
job evacuating New Orleans might consider an attempt to
evacuate San Francisco before the next inevitable
earthquake. There are still residents refusing to leave
the flooded, toxic waste infected, gulf coast. One
of our first process improvements must be to update our
national evacuation policies and procedures.
Trauma
Management – Principles, Performance, and Practices:
Thank everyone for the helping hands they’ve
extended to victims along the gulf. All responders need
to hear: “Whatever you’ve done and continue to do is
helping victims reduce their fear and guilt while they
regain their sense of being in control over a very
traumatic disaster.” Remember, the universe of victims
includes all children. Avoid focusing them on Katrina
and when their in ear shot talk about the positive
progress being made by rescuers and all
responders.
Psychologists tell us the three emotions that impact
victims during every disaster are guilt, fear, and a
sense of being out of control. We all feel guilty
when we see someone in need and can’t reach them in
time. This is particularly true for those responsible
for a safe and healthy environment and the first
responders called on to make quick damage assessments,
estimate the scope of the disaster, and launch an
appropriate response. It’s also true for the
volunteer or neighbor who looses a grip on a survivor at
the last minute or the fireman who missed a victim
during a frantic search. Victims also feel guilty when
they’re forced to leave family, friends and neighbors
behind in harms way. Most Post Traumatic Stress suffered
by war veterans can be traced back to the guilt they had
when they were forced to leave a command under siege.
So
what’s the cure? What can we do to reduce guilt while encouraging process improvements?
Surround yourself and others with non-judgmental
listeners. Avoid those saying “You should have” or “Why
didn’t you!” Encourage those who are out of line
to follow Incident Command System (ICS) recommended
processes so their efforts will be more productive and
benefit more victims. Be good to yourself. Compliment
yourself and others while working through recovery.
Learn from your experiences and share your experience
with others. Remember, we are all in this
together. We’re all victims on our way to recovery.
Fear is driven by not knowing what to expect. As soon
as possible, let the victim know help is on the way and
what the next step might be to get them out of harms
way. Give them something to do. Just saying, “Hold on!”
or “Reach out!” let’s them know what to expect and gives
them a sense of being in control of their future. Think
about the last time you worried about anything and how
good you felt when you got some feedback about the
situation. Continue to provide victims with feedback
about the recovery process.
Our
sense of being in control increases the more we’re
involved in our own recovery.
Focus on keeping the victims involved in the
recovery process. Most victims recover faster when they
feel they are heading home with hammer, nails, and blue
prints than when they’re sitting in a recovery facility
out of harms way.
As
you review the Incident Command System (ICS) structure
and response processes, consider what you might do to
reduce the trauma (guilt, fear, sense of being out of
control) associated with Hurricane Katrina.
The
Incident Command System (ICS) & National Incident
Management System (NIMS)
The
Incident Command System (ICS) and National Incident
Management System (NIMS) are management systems that
have been evolving since the 1940’s. These systems where
originally designed to manage the hundreds of divers
resources needed when fighting forest fires that spread
across department jurisdictions and government’
boundaries. It soon became obvious as responding
agencies specialized and communities signed a variety of
mutual aide agreements that some pre-determined
management structure was needed to reduce the confusion
and trauma present during any response to sudden and
unexpected events. NIMS dates back to the 1970’s and
soon after 9-11 the Department of Homeland Security and
Emergency Government adopted NIMS as a national
standard. As it evolves it is becoming required training
for all law enforcement, fire departments, emergency
governments and Homeland Security personnel. While not
required, NIMS will influence the anticipated response
expected from our schools, hospitals, and communities at
large in the future. The private sector through business
and trade associations are encouraged to have at least a
basic understanding of Incident Command System (ICS).
The Concertina Effect:
Every incident has one “Incident Commander (IC)”
who takes command when arriving on the scene. Most
Incident Command System (ICS) trained agencies require
the first responding officer to take command when making
the first radio contact. The goal is to initiate the
Incident Command System (ICS) quickly so if and when the
incident grows all responders will know who is in charge
and the Incident Command System (ICS) structure will
easily expand. Because the
Incident Command System (ICS) is modular it can expand
and contract as needed. This is referred to as the
“concertina effect.” While the response might move from
a Single Command to a Unified Command when the incident
encompasses more than one agency, or more than one
jurisdiction, or more than one level of government or
any combination of these, there is still only one
Operations Section, Planning Section, Logistics Section
and Finance Section. The goal is for everyone to
come to the incident with knowledge of the ICS so their
Incident Commander can integrate his or her command into
that of the governing Incident Commander. Following is
the basic “Unified Command” structure used during the
Oklahoma City bombing, WTC attacks, hurricanes,
tornados, earthquakes, fires, and terrorist attacks
since the late 1980s.

Incident
Commander:
There is one “Incident Commander (IC) for each incident
so all coordination flows to one person authorized to
act. The IC should be the one most familiar with the
incident. If needed, the IC designates three Command
Staff. “Safety” monitors the scene to ensure its safe
and all responders are qualified, equipped and ready to
roll, “Information” handles the media and makes sure
everyone is informed of facts as they unfold. “Liaison”
coordinates responding agencies when the IC moves from a
“Single Command” to a “Unified Command.”
Operations:
Sets up staging areas to assemble response assets
and coordinate personnel when the IC requests a “strike”
or “mission” operation. For example, a SWAT team might
have to strike first to stop a sniper, followed by
firemen, EMTs, and transporters on a mission to rescue
the injured, followed by engineers and contractors to
rebuild the area.
The operations section
carries out the tactics necessary to achieve the
strategic objectives given by the incident command or
unified command.
Staging
Area(s):
Staging areas
are used to inventory response assets and assemble
personnel at a safe and secure distance from the “Hot
Site.” Staging areas are used to equip, coordinate,
brief, and deploy response personnel.
Planning:
“Strategic” and “Contingency” planners write “incident
action plan(s)” for the duration of the incident based
on the incident goals and strategic objectives
determined by the incident commander or the unified
command. Based on damage assessments and reports from
Operations, plans are written for the next operational
period which may be 8, 12, or 24 48 hours. During
major disasters such as the Oklahoma City bombing, 9-11,
and Hurricane Katrina, long range recovery plans for the
next 6 to 12 months might be proposed.
Logistics:
First determines where the Emergency Operation Center
(EOC) and Staging Areas should be located and than makes
sure they are properly equipped and ready to occupy.
This included providing appropriate table space for
Operations, Planning, Logistics, Finance, and other EOC
personnel, a separate media briefing room and secured
communication links. In addition to monitoring victims,
Logistics is responsible to provide housing, food,
training and incident supplies for all responders.
Finance:
Someone eventually will be asked to pay for the time,
and equipment lost or damaged, personal injuries,
property damage, etc. Finance is responsible for
maintaining personnel records, negotiating mutual aid
contracts, coordinating government assistance programs,
and assisting with insurance claims and other financial
maters requested by the Incident Commander.
NIMS’ Response Processes:
Fast,
effective, complete and successful recovery depends on
an immediate response that’s appropriate to the
incident. Following is a list of recommended action
we’ve learned during our NIMS directed response to the
Oklahoma City bombing, 9-11 terrorist attack, Hurricanes
Ivan, Emily, and Katrina, Tornados in Wisconsin, a train
wreck and BLEVE (Boiling Liquid Expanding Vaporous
Explosion), and earthquakes in California. Post them on
your Operations board at the EOC:
Note to
reader: The following are provided only as a basic guide
for those responding to Katrina. Any reference to the
National Incident Management System (NIMS) published in
March of 2004 is coincidental and is not implied to be
NIMS adopted protocol but rater generally excepted
Incident Command System response procedures.
Refer to Module 6
“Common Responsibilities” of the National Wildfire
Coordinating Group curriculum for additional response
recommendations.
1.
Reporting Instructions:
Get ready, get set, confirm
contact numbers with the EOC, (unless specifically assigned to the Emergency Operations Center (EOC), resources will report to someone in the ICs structure rather than the
Emergency Operations Center (EOC) but don’t report to Operations until summoned by the Incident
Commander. Too many, too much, too soon can add to the
confusion, block critical equipment from reaching
victims and waste valuable time and resources.
a.
You’ll be contacted by Logistics when they’re
ready for your arrival. When you’re called, report to
your assigned staging area with:
i.
A printed inventory of recovery assets you’ve
brought,
ii.
a list of your qualifications, and
iii.
personal identification, to include pictured IDs,
iv.
list of medical limitations and
v.
an adequate supply of medications for at least 14
days.
vi.
You will be logged in, briefed and assigned to
duties by the staging area Operations Chief.
2.
Dress
For Success:
Personal preparation is most important. Depending on the
nature of the incident, anticipated weather, climate,
duration of the event, etc., pack:
a.
Appropriate clothing, work shoes, gloves, eye
protection, head gear, and personal items such as extra
glasses, flash lights and batteries, water packs, back
packs, sun screen, chap sticks, etc.
3.
Family
Briefings:
Before leaving home, hold
“Family Briefings” to ensure everyone is aware of where
you’re going, what you’ll be doing, how to contact you
while gone, and when you estimate you’ll be home.
a.
Arrange
to call a designated telephone number that is equipped
with an answering machine at a specific time each week
to report your status to an adult family member.
4.
Transportation to Staging Area:
Unless instructed by Operations, plan to use provided
transportation to the staging area. Avoid showing up in
vehicles not specifically designed or equipped to be
used by Operations. Car pool when possible to avoid
adding parking, fueling, and maintenance concerns to
Logistic
a.
If your vehicle will be used by Operations, it
will be inspected by security before being introduced
into the pool.
b.
Depending on its use (medical evacuation, mass
transport, law enforcement, etc.) it will be logged into
Operations, a vehicle ID and usage tag will be affixed
to the front window (lower right) and assigned to a
route.
c.
If you’ll be the driver, you’ll also be searched
by security and given an arm ban or ID badge.
d.
Remember to bring extra copies of your medical
limitations list and medications so Operations can
respond to your special needs when requested.
e.
Place confidential medical information in a
sealed envelope with your signature over the seal. The
envelope will only be opened if needed by triage
personnel. You’ll get the sealed envelop back when you
log out of Operations.
5.
Law Enforcement: If you’re responding to Operations as part of Law Enforcement, be
prepared to provide:
a.
Identification, badges, rank, position, job
experience, etc.
b.
Also be prepared to brief the Operations Chief on
your Department’s policy regarding the “use of deadly
force.”
c.
Also, have ready an inventory of weapons and
specialty police equipment you plan to carry during any
strike or mission during recovery.
d.
Remember to bring extra copies of your medical
limitations list and medications so Operations can
respond to your special needs when requested.
e.
Place confidential medical information in a
sealed envelope with your signature over the seal. The
envelope will only be opened if needed by triage
personnel. You’ll get the sealed envelop back when you
log out of Operations.
6.
Fire Fighters and
EMTs: If
you’re responding to Operations as a fire fighter or EMT,
be prepared to provide:
a.
Identification, badges, rank, position, job
experience, etc.
b.
Also be prepared to brief the Operations Chief on
your Department’s policy regarding response processes
and procedures.
c.
Also, have ready an inventory of specialty fire
fighting equipment you brought or are trained to
operate.
d.
Remember to bring extra copies of your medical
limitations list and medications so Operations can
respond to your special needs when requested.
e.
Place confidential medical information in a
sealed envelope with your signature over the seal. The
envelope will only be opened if needed by triage
personnel. You’ll get the sealed envelop back when you
log out of Operations.
7.
Transportation:
If you’re responding to Operations planning to take part
in “Transportation” or “Evacuation” be prepared to
provide:
a.
A pictured ID, driver’ license(s) appropriate to
vehicles you might be asked to drive (CDL, HAZMAT, etc.).
b.
You will be briefed on evacuation routes and
transportation procedures. For example,
Operations might assign you to a counter clockwise route
going one-way in and out of the “Hot Zone.” Remember to
stay far right to allow vehicles to pass on your left.
Park close to curbside at loading points numbered to
correspond to your vehicle.
c.
Expect Transportation to be scheduling vehicle
types along your route depending on victim needs. For
example, your bus might be scheduled to follow an
ambulance and a flat-bed truck will be scheduled behind
you. The goal is to load injured first in ambulances,
than elderly in busses and finally the more mobile on
trucks.
d.
If your vehicle breaks down, pull far right and
flag down the next similar vehicle.
e.
Use your cell phone or radio to report to
Operations. Provide them with your specific location,
the time, description and identification of your
vehicle, your opinion of what’s wrong, and any special
victim needs. Request an estimated time when another
vehicle will be dispatched.
f.
Caution:
There is an inherent danger when entering the Hot Zone
with a vehicle desperately needed by victims during an
evacuation. You will be subject to intimidation and the
possible hostile take over of your vehicle. Operations
will attempt to anticipate such danger and provide you
with an armed escort. However, should it happen, don’t
resist, but rather transport them as directed and report
in as soon as possible to Operations. Your vehicle will
have to be inspected for physical damage, biological
hazards, etc. before being put back into service. Note,
vehicles going into a hostile environment should be
monitored by passive GPS tracking systems.
g.
If you
are forced to transport beyond designated routes or
outside the recovery zone, report specific routes taken,
stops made, businesses visited, etc., to Operations
immediately. Any vehicle or
personnel leaving the Recovery area without being
inspected poses a potential health hazard. Transporting
victims, property or personal items from the Hot Zone
without inspections and decontaminations significantly
endangers anyone who comes in contact with your vehicle.
It might be better to intentionally disable your
vehicle than to allow it to be used.
8.
Special Operations: Includes SWAT, HAZMAT, Helicopter Rescues, Water Search and Rescues,
etc. Special training is required to safely perform
these operations. Report your qualification and
experience to the Incident Commander and Operations
Chief as soon as possible.
9.
Special Services: Most disasters require the support of specials services such as
electricians, plumbers, carpenters, tree trimmers,
landscape architects, bankers, claim adjusters, etc.
Report your special skills and talents to the Incident
Commander and Operations Chief as soon as possible.
Note to reader: Terminology
used in this paper i.e. strikes, missions, hot zone,
recovery zone, and back to normal zone are used similar
to the site terminology used by fire departments when
responding to a hazardous materials incident ( hot zone,
warm zone and cold zone) or law enforcement response to
a crime scene (inner and outer perimeter) etc. When
sharing this information, use the terminology that best
fits your incident command.
Mission Strategies:
The following mission strategies come from Operations
during 9-11, Hurricanes Ivan and Emily, the Oklahoma
City bombing, and various Tornado recoveries using the
National Incident Management System.
Strikes and Missions
should travel in and through the Hot Zone. On the
inbound, in the “Recovery
Zone,” rescuers are equipped, briefed, and
made mission ready. After operating in the
Hot Zone,
they are debriefed, decontaminated, and provided rest
and recuperation in the Recovery Zone before moving
through the “Back to
Normal Zone” and back into the recovery
cycle.
2.
During
a NIMS Operation recovery personnel and assets are
inventoried into and distributed from staging areas in
the “Recovery Zone.”
During evacuations, victims receive physical and
emotional triage in the recovery zone before being
temporarily relocated in the
Back to Normal Zone.
3.
All
victims should be processed through the recovery zone so
they can be tracked by the Red Cross. When they’re
cleared into the Back to
Normal
Zone, they should
have pictured IDs, a record of medical clearance, and if
time permits, a Law Enforcement back ground check. This
will speed their integration into receiving communities
and provide advance information for law enforcement,
school officials, community leaders and neighborhoods
preparing for their arrival. Focus processing on
medical needs first, than financial, and if time permits
on social needs to include pre-qualifying children for
schools and adults for employment. The goal is
to provide welcoming communities with as much as
possible so they can meet the bus and welcome victims by
name while handing them a schedule of settlement
options. All this will add to the victim’s sense of
being in control, reduce their guilt for being dependent
on strangers, and eliminate some fear they have of the
future. Thank them for selecting your community and as
soon as possible introduce them to business leaders and
associations, veteran’s organizations, social groups,
etc. Get them involved in their own recovery through
scheduled meeting on Katrina recovery efforts. Provide
them with a list of all efforts being made within your
community and put them in contact with the Incident
Commanders for each group. Your goal is to keep them in
contact with their home town and ready them to return as
soon as possible.
ü
Keep standard Incident Command System (ICS) daily logs
for future review and process improvement.
As
soon as victims are cleared into the
“Back to
Normal Zone,”
forward a copy of your tracking and victim clearing
records to the appropriate State Incident Commander of
Emergency Government.
Risk
Management – Managing the “pure” and “speculative” risks
created by any sudden, unexpected, life threatening
event!
The Incident
Command System (ICS) provides
the structure and control needed to rescue victims and
ensure an efficient response.
How quickly victims are reached and how quickly they
recover depends on the scope of the incident, percent of
responders familiar with the Incident Command
System (ICS) , and your ability to manage the pure and
speculative risks created by the incident.
Pure risks
only create loss. Speculative risks offer a chance for
gain but could result in a loss. For example,
hurricanes, tornados, terrorist attacks, and auto
accidents are all pure risk that when they occur result
in both physical and emotional loss. Managing the risk
of looters after Katrina is a primary reason victims
refused to evacuate. The impulse act of giving after
disasters increases your speculative risks. Expect
increased internet frauds, credit card scams, phishing
and pharming, attempts, money laundering, forgeries, and
embezzlements. Expect criminals to play on your guilt,
fears, and sense of being out of control to lower your
defenses and encourage impulse giving. Share your
knowledge of the Incident Command System (ICS)
with your local law enforcement, fire fighters, schools,
churches, and business
community. Encourage them
to register all their efforts to assist victims with
their local Director of Emergency Management.
That will help document
their giving, place them in the national NIMS Operations
Staging Area, and ensure the greatest benefits reach the
victims who are most in need.
Where do we go? What
do we do? How do we get started?
I
suggest you visit the National Emergency Resource
Registry at:
https://www.swern.gov/.
Next
go to the Red Cross web site at:
http://www.redcross.org/ and consider volunteering.
And
than, visit your local Red Cross through:
http://www.redcross.org/where/chapts.asp
to
donate at:
https://give.redcross.org/donation-form.asp?hurricanemasthead.
You
can help victims locate family through:
http://www.familylinks.icrc.org/katrina
You can
gain more information about the Incident Command System
(ICS) and the National Incident Management System (NIMS)
at; www.fema.gov/nims
Visit any major news media and trade association web sites for
links to victims in need. But,
beware of
criminal phishing and pharming.
Phishing involves criminals placing look-a-like web
sites on the web to capture credit card numbers and
personal access codes they’ll use to divert donations to
their accounts. Pharming is an extension of phishing
that leads you through a variety of links to their
accounts.
NIMS works for individuals, business, associations,
groups, industries, communities, cities, counties,
states, or countries.
Benefits
include: Better communications because everyone
uses the same terminology and speaks the same “system”
language. Operation’s missions are focused and
effective. Planning ensures everyone is on the same page
and moving in the same direction. Logistics ensures
safety and appropriate care for responders, and Finance
tracks the cost and ensures the bills will be paid.
Complete recoveries depend on reliable communications,
systematic planning, dependable logistics, and managed
financing. The National Incident Management System
works. Let it work for you! Share your knowledge
of NIMS with others.

|